Althouse on Craig-gate

Ann Althouse offers her two pence on the Craig affair. She criticizes a post by Arianna Huffington which stakes out a position somewhat similar to mine (Huffington, overplays the rhetorical terrorism card, in my humble opinion). Althouse makes several fair points in her criticism (though also uses a strawperson argument) and ends her post with an interesting rational-choice economic argument supporting the enforcement of so called "quality-of-life" crime investigations:

I'm not an economist, but it seems to me that the sting is cost effective. One police officer, carrying out very few arrests, ruins the reputation of this bathroom as a place for sex encounters. That bathroom is in the state's most important airport, a hub of commercial activity. Minnesotans have a huge interest in maintaining the quality of their international airport, and travelers have endless opportunities to choose other routes when they dislike an airport. I would speculate that Karsnia's work probably produced a large net benefit to taxpayers.

Having said that, someone in the comments thread referring to him/herself as EngimatiCore countered with an equally reasonable counter-argument.

...unless Sen. Craig was one of the first arrests by any officer in that bathroom. I think it is clear that the reputation of that bathroom had been unscathed at the time of the incident, and probably would still be had this not broken nationally.

I would bet that a cop stationed, in uniform, outside of the bathroom would work just as well. People would not have to 'go looking' for him, we would be further from the line of entrapment, and the cop would not be forced to spend his time on a commode.

Of course this reasoned discourse can't stand for long among the commenters of the Althouse blog. First troll A makes some silly sweeping generalization of the right, "The GOP Mantra...", followed by an equally sweeping generalization of the left, "You just repeat the same questions over and over again, while ignoring the debate that has previously occurred in response to such questions." And the troll baiting continues.

But to Ann and EnigmatiCore, I salute you.